Also known as
Phantom equity, phantom stock, Equity Value Ownership Plan (EVOP), or value participation plan.
Suitable for
Synthetic equity suits owners who want to share the upside of the business with employees but prefer not to bring them onto the share register, whether for legal, personal or structural reasons. It's particularly useful where the disclosure obligations that come with real share ownership are a concern, or where the corporate structure makes issuing shares complicated. Payouts are also generally deductible to the company, much like traditional bonuses.
Synthetic plans also offer practical flexibility. Awards can be tailored person by person or based on a formula, and unvested awards are typically forfeited when someone leaves, while real shares are hard to take back. There are no minority shareholders to consult and no shares to buy back from departing employees. Established businesses with steady cash flow are often well placed to fund the payouts.
It can serve as a stepping stone, too. Some owners use a synthetic plan to build an ownership culture first, then introduce real shares or options once both sides are ready.
What's in it for employees
Employees participate in value growth without investing their own money. RSUs, DSUs and SARs can provide meaningful rewards tied to company performance, on top of traditional annual bonuses. And in some structures, employees may be able to ultimately roll their units into real equity, which can offer more favourable tax treatment on future growth.
Key Considerations
Tax treatment. Payouts are generally taxed as employment income rather than as capital gains, so employees bring the full payout into income and can't use the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption (LCGE). Employees should understand this difference if asked to compare synthetic equity with real share ownership.
Funding the payouts. Because payouts are usually made in cash, the company needs to plan how it will fund them, whether from cash flow or, for plans that pay out on a sale, from the sale proceeds.
Clear plan terms. A unitholder agreement should define every trigger event, such as death, disability, termination, resignation, and retirement, and set a clear valuation method for each. Clear terms from the outset avoid disputes later.
Owner liquidity. Synthetic equity doesn't provide cash to the owner, so if liquidity is part of the goal, it's often paired with a structure that does.
Making it feel real. Because employees don't hold shares, regular updates on how the business is performing help them see the link between their work and their reward.
Getting the design right. An experienced advisor can tailor the type of units, the triggers and the valuation method to your goals, and help you communicate the plan clearly to employees, so it rewards the right people and helps them embrace an ownership mindset.
We do not provide tax or legal advice and the content of this page should not be taken as such.