Glossary of terms

Hybrid Structures

Sometimes one structure alone doesn't meet all of an owner's goals. A hybrid employee ownership structure combines two structures in one company. 

Some examples of hybrid structures are: EOT and Share Purchase Plan, Share Purchase and Stock Options, or MBO and minority Share Purchase. 

To illustrate this concept, let’s look at an EOT and Share Purchase Plan Hybrid. An Employee Ownership Trust (EOT) holds a controlling interest on behalf of all eligible employees, while a select group of employees, usually future leaders, buy a minority stake directly through a key person share purchase plan.

An EOT is designed to share the wealth equitably: benefits go to the whole workforce under allocation rules based on length of service, remuneration and hours worked. That's its strength. But a company may also want to attract or keep a promising leader who is taking on more responsibility and expects a reward to match. An EOT doesn't necessarily offer that. Direct share ownership can.

This is one common example of a hybrid structure. Different employee ownership models can be combined in other ways too, depending on the owner's goals and the business's needs.

How it works
  • The EOT sale: the owner sells a controlling interest to the EOT. A qualifying sale can benefit from the $10 million capital gains exemption.
  • The direct stake: key employees acquire a minority stake, usually by buying shares directly from the owner, typically alongside the EOT sale. Alternatively, the company can issue new shares to them from its treasury, either at the time of the sale or later.
  • Working together: the company's articles and a shareholder agreement set out how the trust and the direct shareholders work together on decisions, dividends and exits.
Also known as

Layered ownership, EOT with direct employee shareholders, or a combined EOT and key person share purchase plan.

Suitable for

Owners who want what an EOT sale offers, including the $10 million capital gains exemption and broad-based employee ownership, but also want to give certain employees a meaningful direct stake. These are often the future leaders who will succeed the selling owners. Direct share ownership isn't bound by the allocation rules an EOT must follow, so it can be shaped to reward the people who will take the company forward.

The hybrid works particularly well where there is a clearly defined group of future leaders who want to invest directly in the business. Where affordability is a concern, the financing options described under Share Purchase Plans can help make the investment more accessible.

What's in it for employees

Employees benefit on two levels. All eligible employees share in the company's performance through the EOT, without investing their own money. Direct shareholders also hold a minority stake with shareholder rights. When they eventually sell, their gains are generally taxed as capital gains, with potential access to the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption (LCGE), provided the shares qualify.

Key Considerations

Administration. A hybrid means two structures to manage. The EOT is simple on this front: it is always one shareholder, however many employees benefit, and its shares rarely move. Direct shareholders need more careful record-keeping, including the share register, articles, share certificates and a regular valuation.

Keeping the EOT in control. The EOT must keep its controlling interest, so there is a ceiling on how much can be held directly via share purchases. Any future share issuance should be modelled to make sure the trust's control is maintained.

The 10% threshold. Employees who build a significant direct stake, generally 10% or more of any class of shares, can’t also be EOT beneficiaries. Future leaders should understand this trade-off before they buy in, though in practice a direct stake of that size will normally be worth more to them than what they would receive as an EOT beneficiary. 

One consistent valuation. Both transactions should rest on the same independent valuation, so the price the trust pays and the price employees pay are consistent and defensible.

Clear communication. Clear eligibility rules for direct ownership, and consistent communication about the goals behind the structure, help everyone see how the two levels of ownership work together.

Getting the structure right. The share structure, the shareholder agreement and the fit between the two plans shape every future issuance, departure and exit. An experienced advisor can design these pieces to work together from the outset, so the shared ownership of the EOT and the incentive of direct ownership reinforce each other.

We do not provide tax or legal advice and the content of this page should not be taken as such.